Updated 21 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

Orolay vs Oyster and Arrow

Orolay logo

Orolay

No. 11 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses9.0

Pick Orolay for a lower entry price ($71.99 against $132) and a lower free-delivery threshold ($49 against $150).

Oyster and Arrow logo

Oyster and Arrow

No. 14 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses8.8

Pick Oyster and Arrow for free returns.

See the category

Key differences

  • Orolay scores higher overall: 9.0 against 8.8.
  • Orolay has a lower entry price ($71.99 against $132).
  • Only Oyster and Arrow has free returns.
  • Orolay has a lower free-delivery threshold ($49 against $150).
  • Among support channels, only Orolay offers Chat.

Side by side

Orolay vs Oyster and Arrow
Orolay logoOrolayOyster and Arrow logoOyster and Arrow
Cost
Price from$71.99Lower$132in the highest quarter of 84 brands
Free delivery threshold$49Lowerin the lowest quarter of 154 brands$150in the highest quarter of 154 brands
CertificationsGrsOeko-Tex
Other facts
ProductsWomenswear, Menswear, Coats jackets, Dresses, LoungewearWomenswear, Loungewear
MaterialsWool, LinenCotton, Linen
MarketsUnited States, United Kingdom, Japan, CanadaUnited States
Delivery and service
Return window30 days30 days
Free returnsNoYes
Company
Legal entityJiaxing Zichi Trading CO.LTD.Oyster and Arrow
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited States
Founded2012Not listed
Support channelsEmail, Chat, Help centreEmail, Help centre

Part scores

Orolay

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.1
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.0
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.5

Oyster and Arrow

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more8.5
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.1
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.5

Our verdict on each

Orolay

Orolay suits shoppers who want coats, jackets and loungewear without a big entry cost, with puffers from $71.99 and free standard shipping on orders over $49. The trade-off is returns: 30 days for U.S. orders with a return shipping fee taken off your refund, which suits buyers near US warehouses.

Read the full Orolay review

Oyster and Arrow

Oyster and Arrow suits shoppers who want organic bamboo pajama sets, napkin sets and swimwear in a Hamptons and Montauk toile print, and who want an easy way back. Entry pricing sits at $132, returns run 30 days after delivery with the return label supplied.

Read the full Oyster and Arrow review

If neither fits

How they place

Basics, t-shirts and loungewear
Orolay 9 of 240 by score · Oyster and Arrow 13 of 240 by score

Pros and cons

Orolay

Pros

  • Puffers start at $71.99, which keeps the entry cost down on coats and jackets.
  • Free standard shipping applies once an order passes $49.
  • The return window is 30 days, counted from the shipping date rather than from delivery.

Cons

  • A flat return shipping fee is deducted from your refund, so the amount that comes back is smaller than the amount paid.
  • Free standard shipping needs an order over $49, so a small order can still carry a delivery charge.
  • The 30 day return window is quoted for orders shipped in the United States, so buyers ordering into another market should read their own terms before buying.

Oyster and Arrow

Pros

  • A 30-day window after delivery to request a return, with a return shipping label supplied once it is accepted
  • Organic bamboo with OEKO-TEX certification, plus cotton napkin sets and linen pillow shams
  • Entry price of $132, with free delivery on orders over $150

Cons

  • Support runs by email and a help centre, and a phone or live chat route is not among email and help centre
  • Everyday clothing is not among the product types it sells, which are organic bamboo pajama sets, cotton napkin sets, linen pillow shams and swimwear

Who each suits

Orolay

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want coats, jackets, dresses and loungewear from the same brand.
  • Readers who want shorter delivery times by ordering from one of the brand’s warehouse markets.
  • Value shoppers who want a recycled-content standard on the record for the fabrics the store names.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who expect return shipping to be free, since a flat fee is taken off the refund before the money reaches you.
  • Buyers ordering from outside the warehouse markets, because the 30 day window is stated for orders shipped in the United States.
  • Readers hoping for a coat priced under $71.99, the figure quoted for the Cosmos Chrome Cropped Down Puffer.

Oyster and Arrow

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want organic bamboo pajama sets with a Hamptons and Montauk toile print
  • Gift buyers looking at napkin sets and pillow shams in cotton and linen
  • Anyone who wants a 30-day return window with the return postage covered

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who need delivery outside the United States
  • Buyers after everyday clothing beyond pajama sets, napkin sets, pillow shams and swimsuits
  • Shoppers who want phone or live chat support

Current offers

Orolay

  • Discount code

    Subscribe and get 15% off first purchase

    Newsletter signup, first purchase, full-price items only

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Oyster and Arrow

  • Discount code

    15% off your first order for email subscribers

    Sign up with email on the site for first access to new destination prints, limited drops, sales and restocks.

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Questions about each

Orolay

What does Orolay actually sell?

Orolay sells womenswear, with coats and jackets, dresses and loungewear filling out the catalogue. The pieces the storefront puts forward include a maxi coat and a maxi dress, so outerwear and easy summer dressing sit at the centre rather than tailored workwear. The fabrics the store names are wool and linen, which is what to read on when comparing cloth between stores.

What does a puffer from Orolay cost, and is delivery free?

The lowest listing quoted is the Cosmos Chrome Cropped Down Puffer at $71.99, which sets the entry point for outerwear. Standard shipping is free on orders over $49, so a seasonal basket clears delivery while a lighter one pays for it. Prices are in US dollars, so the figure reads the same way wherever you order from.

Oyster and Arrow

How much does Oyster and Arrow cost?

The entry price is $132, which is the regular price of the Hamptons and Montauk Toile long sleeve bamboo pajama set. Other pieces in the range may sit at different levels. Delivery also shapes the total: orders over $150 ship free, while smaller orders pay a delivery charge on top.

How long do I have to return something?

You have 30 days after receiving an item to request a return. Once a return is accepted, the brand sends a return shipping label along with instructions on where and how to send the package, so you are not left covering the return postage yourself. Starting the process means a written request.

Sources

Orolay

  • orolay.com: 12 facts, checked 1 October 2026

Oyster and Arrow

  • oysterandarrow.com: 11 facts, checked 1 October 2026