Updated 21 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

Oyster and Arrow vs Thesupermade

Oyster and Arrow logo

Oyster and Arrow

No. 14 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses8.8

Pick Oyster and Arrow for free returns.

Thesupermade logo

Thesupermade

No. 4 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses8.8

Pick Thesupermade for more markets (14 against 1).

See the category

Key differences

  • Only Oyster and Arrow has free returns.
  • Among products, only Thesupermade offers T shirts, Shirts and Knitwear.
  • Among materials, only Oyster and Arrow offers Linen.
  • Among materials, only Thesupermade offers Denim.
  • Thesupermade has more markets (14 against 1).

Side by side

Oyster and Arrow vs Thesupermade
Oyster and Arrow logoOyster and ArrowThesupermade logoThesupermade
Cost
Price from$132€25.95
Free delivery threshold$150€109
CertificationsOeko-TexNot listed
Other facts
ProductsWomenswear, LoungewearT shirts, Shirts, Loungewear, Knitwear, Coats jackets, Jeans
+ 2 moreBasics, Womenswear
MaterialsCotton, LinenCotton, Denim
MarketsUnited StatesUnited States, Canada, Germany, United Kingdom, France, Italy
+ 8 moreAustralia, Spain, Japan, Israel, Singapore, Switzerland, Hong Kong, South Africa
Delivery and service
Return window30 days30 days
Free returnsYesNo
Company
Legal entityOyster and ArrowNot listed
HeadquartersUnited StatesNot listed
FoundedNot listed2021
Support channelsEmail, Help centreEmail, Help centre

Part scores

Oyster and Arrow

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more8.5
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.1
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.5

Thesupermade

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.1
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more8.8
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.1

Our verdict on each

Oyster and Arrow

Oyster and Arrow suits shoppers who want organic bamboo pajama sets, napkin sets and swimwear in a Hamptons and Montauk toile print, and who want an easy way back. Entry pricing sits at $132, returns run 30 days after delivery with the return label supplied.

Read the full Oyster and Arrow review

Thesupermade

Thesupermade suits shoppers building an everyday wardrobe: it sells t shirts, loungewear and more from €25.95 and gives 30 days to request a return after a parcel lands. Return postage is yours to pay, and small orders sit under the free delivery bar.

Read the full Thesupermade review

If neither fits

How they place

Basics, t-shirts and loungewear
Oyster and Arrow 13 of 240 by score · Thesupermade 4 of 240 by score

Pros and cons

Oyster and Arrow

Pros

  • A 30-day window after delivery to request a return, with a return shipping label supplied once it is accepted
  • Organic bamboo with OEKO-TEX certification, plus cotton napkin sets and linen pillow shams
  • Entry price of $132, with free delivery on orders over $150

Cons

  • Support runs by email and a help centre, and a phone or live chat route is not among email and help centre
  • Everyday clothing is not among the product types it sells, which are organic bamboo pajama sets, cotton napkin sets, linen pillow shams and swimwear

Thesupermade

Pros

  • A return can be requested for 30 days from the day the order reaches you, covering a size that does not fit and a change of mind.
  • Free delivery starts at €109, so orders that clear that bar are not charged for shipping.
  • Prices begin at €25.95, so a first order is a small commitment rather than a wardrobe-sized one.

Cons

  • Free returns are not offered, so a size swap or a change of mind leaves the return postage with you.
  • Support runs on email and help centre, so a fit or delivery question waits on a written answer.

Who each suits

Oyster and Arrow

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want organic bamboo pajama sets with a Hamptons and Montauk toile print
  • Gift buyers looking at napkin sets and pillow shams in cotton and linen
  • Anyone who wants a 30-day return window with the return postage covered

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who need delivery outside the United States
  • Buyers after everyday clothing beyond pajama sets, napkin sets, pillow shams and swimsuits
  • Shoppers who want phone or live chat support

Thesupermade

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want 30 days to try pieces at home before deciding, and who can cover postage when a fit is wrong.
  • Anyone ordering enough to clear €109 and have delivery free.
  • Shoppers starting an everyday wardrobe from the €25.95 entry price instead of paying for a full outfit at once.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who expect the brand to cover return postage, since free returns are not offered.
  • Anyone who needs help spoken rather than written, since contact runs through email and a help centre.

Current offers

Oyster and Arrow

  • Discount code

    15% off your first order for email subscribers

    Sign up with email on the site for first access to new destination prints, limited drops, sales and restocks.

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Thesupermade

  • Discount code

    15% off for newsletter subscribers: 15% off first order, no minimum

    Subscribe to the mailing list; one code per order, each code valid once

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Questions about each

Oyster and Arrow

How much does Oyster and Arrow cost?

The entry price is $132, which is the regular price of the Hamptons and Montauk Toile long sleeve bamboo pajama set. Other pieces in the range may sit at different levels. Delivery also shapes the total: orders over $150 ship free, while smaller orders pay a delivery charge on top.

How long do I have to return something?

You have 30 days after receiving an item to request a return. Once a return is accepted, the brand sends a return shipping label along with instructions on where and how to send the package, so you are not left covering the return postage yourself. Starting the process means a written request.

Thesupermade

How long do I have to request a return after my order arrives?

You have 30 days from the day your order is delivered to ask for a return. That window covers a size that does not fit and an item you have changed your mind about, and the request goes through the store’s returns process.

Does it cost anything to send clothes back?

Free returns are not offered, so the return postage comes with you whether the size is wrong or your mind has changed. The clock is still 30 days from delivery, which is roomy, but the shipping on the way back is a cost you carry.

Sources

Oyster and Arrow

  • oysterandarrow.com: 11 facts, checked 1 October 2026

Thesupermade

  • thesupermade.com: 9 facts, checked 1 October 2026