Updated 18 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

Top sneakers compared

183 brands, ranked on the terms we checked.

Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.

What matters most
BrandScoreReturn windowPrice fromFree returnsWorn-shoe returns
  • 1

    CAT Footwear

    Top pick

    Best for: Work boots and casual sneakers with free returns on worn pairs.

    9.2
    30 days
    $124.95
    Yes
    Yes
    Return window
    30 days
    Price from
    $124.95
    Not listed
    Free returns
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who want boots and sneakers from the same brand and want 30 days to change their mind.
    • People who would rather deal with a company based in the United States than an unlisted reseller.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers who want a longer trial than 30 days before footwear has to go back.
    • Anyone who needs an extra wide or narrow fitting has to adjust the size choice.
    Worn-shoe returns
    Yes
    Markets
    United States, Canada, United Kingdom, and 19 more
    Legal entity
    Wolverine World Wide, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Support channels
    Chat, Phone, Help centre
    Read review

About this ranking

The trade-off is plain: a low entry price often buys less room to change your mind, and a long return window tends to show up in the price. Each shop quotes in its own currency, so euro sellers are read against euro sellers rather than against dollar and pound shelves. Returns sort the field just as sharply: Shoe Carnival allows 60 days, most of the field allows about a month, and Bader's window is shorter.

How we picked

The order below leans on what a sneaker buyer actually decides: the price at the till, the length and cost of the return window, the widths the label cuts, and how far the shop delivers. Entry price carries weight because trainers are often bought on a budget, but a low number means little if the return window is short or the last runs narrow. Return length sits right beside it, followed by whether return postage is covered and which support channels are open when a size has to be swapped. Markets matter for readers outside the home country, since a wide shoe range in a single market is of little use to someone ordering from another. Figures come from each seller's own pages: delivery, returns, imprint and category pages, plus corporate history pages for founding years, and where a shop runs several national sites the numbers describe one of them.

How we rank

What to look for

The price at the till
Entry prices spread widely. Read prices within one currency, since dollar and pound shops do not line up with euro listings.
A return window you can use
Shoe Carnival allows 60 days, Deichmann and Coes allow 30 days, and Bader's window is shorter. A tight window is workable only when the size you need is in stock, so check availability before relying on it.
Who pays for the return
Free returns at Bader, Deichmann, Fashion Days, OTTO, PUMA, Shoe Carnival and Birkenstock put no cost on a size swap.
The last the label cuts
Width decides whether a sneaker fits at all. Deichmann cuts wide and extra wide pairs, which suits feet that need room, while other shops sit at the opposite end. A wrong last is the quickest reason for a pair to come back.
Where it ships
Deichmann delivers to 24 countries including Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Bulgaria, so its shoe range is reachable across much of Europe, while several rivals serve a single market. Check the delivery page for your country before ordering a size you cannot try in a shop.
A way to reach a person
When a size is wrong you want a person on the other end. Bader handles questions through email, phone and help centre, and PUMA offers email, phone, help centre and more for cases that suit answers from other buyers.

Questions

Who pays when a pair goes back?

Free returns at Bader, Deichmann, Fashion Days, OTTO, PUMA, Shoe Carnival and Birkenstock mean a size swap costs nothing extra. That changes the real cost of a near miss, and it matters most when you are ordering a width or a size you have never worn.

Which of these is cheapest to start from?

Prices are quoted in several currencies, so read them within their own group. A low entry price does not buy a longer return window.

Who cuts wider or narrower fits?

Width is the quiet reason a pair comes back. Bader lists regular and wide fits and Birkenstock runs narrow and regular, so a wide foot has somewhere to go at both. Deichmann is the broadest of the shoe sellers, while OTTO sits at the narrow end of the scale, so a wide-footed buyer would read the size chart carefully before ordering.

Shoe specialist or clothing marketplace?

Start from what you are buying. Fashion Days, Amiclubwear and Coes are clothing sellers whose return terms are useful comparison points, and PUMA appears here as a brand-owned store. A sneaker purchase sits more comfortably with a seller whose range is shoes.

Keep comparing