Start with the fit label, not the shoe name
Comfort, wide-fit and barefoot shoes are three different promises about the space around your foot, and retailers apply the labels at different levels of detail. DEICHMANN lists comfort shoes, wide-fit and barefoot shoes as separate product types, which makes it the clearest starting point for a shopper who wants to see all three side by side. Its width grading covers wide and extra wide, so a wide pair and an extra-wide pair sit on the same rail.
BADER lists comfort shoes among its product types but grades widths as regular and wide. That means a shopper who needs genuine extra-wide volume will not find it under a width label here, and should judge BADER on the comfort and regular pairs instead.
OTTO lists narrow only, so it does not serve as the place to shop if extra width is the deciding factor. Use the BADER review and OTTO review to confirm what the listings actually show before you plan a basket.
Price floors tell you which retailer to sort first
The cheapest entry point in each catalogue sets how much a trial pair will cost. BADER therefore opens at the lowest floor, DEICHMANN sits in the middle and OTTO opens highest.
Read those figures as floors rather than averages, and pair them with the range ranking for Comfort, wide-fit and barefoot shoes to see how these three sit against wider-rated options such as Birkenstock, Coes and Muck Boot.
Upper material decides how a wide shoe behaves
Leather gives in over time, while canvas and rubber hold their shape, so materials tell you how a wide or barefoot design settles after wear. BADER and OTTO both list leather, canvas and rubber, giving a leather option plus softer and springier alternatives. DEICHMANN lists leather and canvas, so its range leans towards leather and canvas.
Barefoot shoes in particular reward a close look at materials, because a flexible upper that starts tight can ease across the forefoot while a stiff one stays fixed. Shoppers comparing that behaviour should check the DEICHMANN review alongside dedicated barefoot makers.
Returns are the real trial period
A wide or barefoot fit is hard to predict, so the return window is what makes a first pair affordable. DEICHMANN and OTTO both give 30 days, and BADER gives 14 days. All three retailers also offer free returns, which removes the postage cost from the risk.
Across the wider ratings in our data the return window runs 14 to 60 days, so a shorter window is not unusual in this category. Support matters as much as the window: DEICHMANN and BADER offer email, phone and help centre, and OTTO adds chat to help centre, chat, phone and more, which is handy when a size question sits between two grades.
Delivery thresholds and where each retailer ships
Order size matters here: a wide-fit shopper buying one pair may fall under a threshold that a household order clears easily.
Reach decides whether that threshold matters. DEICHMANN ships to 24 countries including Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Bulgaria, OTTTO to Germany, and BADER to 5 countries including Austria, Germany and Sweden. A shopper outside those lists should treat DEICHMANN’s reach as the deciding factor.
Check the wider catalogue and extras after the fit
Once fit, price and returns look right, the rest of the catalogue explains what a returning shopper can add to an order. BADER covers womenswear, underwear and more, DEICHMANN covers womenswear, kidswear and more and OTTO covers womenswear, kidswear and more. DEICHMANN also runs a loyalty programme, as does OTTO.
Company facts confirm the counterparties and longevity. BADER was founded in 1929 and trades as Bader-Versand Ges.m.b.H. from Austria. DEICHMANN was founded in 1913 and its UK entity is DEICHMANN-SHOES UK Ltd., headquartered in Germany. OTTO was founded in 1949 as Otto GmbH & Co. KGaA, also based in Germany. Read the full OTTO review for the surrounding detail.