In short
Worn-shoe returns mean a shop takes back shoes already worn outdoors rather than only unworn pairs.
Worn-shoe returns describe a shop’s stance on footwear that has been worn outdoors. Some shops accept a pair once it has been outside and even broken in, because shoes are expected to be tried on. Others accept only unworn footwear, often with the box and tags intact. On the shops compared here, worn returns are no at 4 ELEMENTOS, at 5.11 Tactical and at aeyde, so check the return window before you wear a pair outside.