Updated 18 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

PLENTY review

PLENTYNo. 131 of 196 in women's shoes, heels and sandals

9.2
See alternatives
9.2
out of 10No. 131 of 196 in women's shoes, heels and sandalsFacts checked 1 Oct 2026

Best for: Canadian shoppers buying women’s shoes who want a firm return deadline and store credit as an option.

Return window
30 days
Price from
CA$100
Free returns
No
Worn-shoe returns
No

Alternatives to PLENTY

See all 196 ranked →

Our verdict

Plenty is a Canadian clothing shop whose women’s shoes list from CAD 100 and can be returned within 30 days of the shipping date. It suits shoppers who want leather and suede styles in the same basket and would rather take store credit than chase a refund, though every online return carries a restocking fee.

Fits you if

  • Shoppers who want a firm deadline, since returns close 30 days after the shipping date.
  • People content with store credit or an exchange rather than a card refund.
  • Buyers looking for leather or suede women’s footwear in a single store order.

Look elsewhere if

  • Anyone outside Canada, which is the only market it delivers in.
  • Shoppers who expect returns to cost nothing, since online returns are subject to a restocking fee.
  • Anyone hoping to send back a worn pair, because footwear has to come back unworn and in original condition.

Key facts

Cost and Other facts
Price from
CA$100
Markets
Canada
Products
Sneakers, Boots, Flats, Loafers, Heels, Sandals
Materials
Leather, Suede
Delivery and service
Return window
30 days
Free returns
No
Worn-shoe returns
No
Company
Legal entity
Plenty Stores
Headquarters
Canada
Founded
1989
Support channels
Email, Phone, Help centre
Official website
getplenty.com

Facts checked 1 October 2026, 7 sources

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Returns stay open 30 days from the shipping date, with an exchange or store credit offered inside that window.
  • Women’s footwear covers sneakers, boots and heels, among other styles, so plenty of a wardrobe can come from a single store.
  • Delivery reaches Canada, and the store states plainly that it does not ship beyond that market.
  • Plenty Stores has been trading since 1989, so the name sits on a long record rather than a recent launch.

Cons

  • Every online return is subject to a restocking fee.
  • Footwear has to come back unwashed, unworn and undamaged, so anything already worn cannot be returned.
  • The store stops taking returns 30 days after the shipping date.

What it does well

Plenty gives you 30 days counted from the shipping date to send a pair back, and inside that window it offers an exchange or store credit. Two conditions decide whether a return actually lands well. Online returns are subject to a restocking fee, so even a returnable order costs extra to send back. Footwear also has to return in original condition, which the policy spells out as not washed, worn or damaged, meaning a pair you have already broken in is past its moment. Read the two together and the picture is clear: the window is workable, the condition test is strict, and a free return is not part of the deal.

Who runs it

The company behind the store is Plenty Stores, whose customer service address sits in Canada. It has been trading since 1989, so the store carries a long record behind the name rather than being a recent addition. Customer questions go to email, phone and help centre, with weekday office hours for anyone who would rather talk than type. If you are trying to reach someone at the weekend, the written channel is the route that stays open.

Questions

What does a pair of women’s shoes cost at Plenty?

One listed style, the BILLINI Gaynor Kitten Heels in chocolate shine, shows CAD 100 as its regular price. Prices differ style by style across the collection, so treat that figure as a starting point for a single pair rather than a level that applies to everything you browse.

How long do I have to return a pair of shoes?

You have 30 days counted from the shipping date, not from the day the parcel reaches you. Inside that window Plenty offers an exchange or store credit. The returns page is explicit that returns are not accepted once the window has passed, so the earlier of those two dates is the one that counts.

Does it cost anything to send an order back?

PLENTY starts at CA$100. Online returns are subject to a restocking fee, so sending something back is not free even inside the 30 day window. The charge applies to online returns across the store, which is worth factoring in on a lower-priced pair before you order rather than after.

Can I return shoes I have already worn?

No. Footwear has to go back in original condition, which the policy spells out as not washed, worn or damaged. Anything already worn cannot be returned, even well inside the 30 day window, so try a pair indoors and check the fit before it gets a proper outing.

Will I get a refund or store credit?

The returns page names an exchange or store credit inside the 30 day window counted from the shipping date. Store credit holds the value with the retailer for a later order, while an exchange swaps the item for another of the kind you picked, so neither route hands the money straight back.

Where does Plenty deliver?

Delivery is to Canada. The delivery and returns page also states that the store is unable to deliver outside Canada at this time, so shoppers further afield are not covered by this store’s shipping and would need a retailer in their own market instead.

How long has Plenty been trading, and who runs it?

Plenty has been a shopping destination in Canada since 1989, and the company behind the store is Plenty Stores. Its customer service address sits in Canada, and both the returns page and the terms point readers to that same place for anything about an order.

Sources

  • getplenty.com checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Founded, Products

    “Visit Plenty, a shopping destination for men's and women's clothing in Canada since 1989.”

  • getplenty.com/collections/womens-shoes checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Materials

    “BIRKENSTOCK - Amsterdam Wrapped Suede Clog; VAGABOND - Hedda Ankle Boots (Hedda Stretch Leather Ankle Boot)”

  • getplenty.com/collections/womens-shoes checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Price from

    “BILLINI - Gaynor Kitten Heels - Chocolate Shine - Regular price $100.00”

  • getplenty.com/pages/delivery-returns checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Free returns, Markets, Return window, Worn-shoe returns

    “All online returns are subject to a $7.00 restocking fee.”

  • getplenty.com/pages/faqs checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Support channels

    “General Inquiries: info@getplenty.com ... Call Monday - Friday, 9AM - 4PM PST 604-428-3070 or Toll Free 1-833-946-1763”

  • getplenty.com/pages/payment-privacy checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Legal entity

    “Plenty Stores Attn: Customer Service 1352 Vernon Drive Vancouver, BC V6A 3P7”

  • getplenty.com/pages/terms-of-service checked 1 October 2026

    Backs: Headquarters

    “Plenty Stores Attn: Customer Service 1352 Vernon Drive Vancouver, BC V6A 3P7”

Compiled from 7 source pages, checked 1 October 2026. We did not open an account.