Updated 21 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

Mack Weldon vs Phase Eight

Mack Weldon

8.8

Best for: Shoppers who want a clear return window and a readable entry price for everyday basics.

Phase Eight logo

Phase Eight

8.7

Best for: One catalog for womenswear, workwear and denim, with petite and plus sizes in the same place.

See the category

Key differences

  • Mack Weldon scores higher overall: 8.8 against 8.7.
  • Mack Weldon has a longer return window (30 days against 28 days).
  • Among support channels, only Phase Eight offers Phone.
  • Mack Weldon is available in 28 more countries.
  • Among products, only Mack Weldon offers Menswear, T shirts and Shirts.

Side by side

Mack Weldon vs Phase Eight
Mack WeldonPhase Eight logoPhase Eight
Cost
Price from€56£89
Free delivery threshold€180£150
Other facts
ProductsMenswear, T shirts, Shirts, Basics, Loungewear, Knitwear
+ 2 moreCoats jackets, Jeans
Womenswear, Dresses, Occasion wear, Workwear, Knitwear, Coats jackets
+ 3 moreJeans, Petite, Plus size
MaterialsCotton, Linen, Wool, Cashmere, Silk, TencelCotton, Organic cotton, Linen, Recycled polyester, Leather
MarketsUnited States, Australia, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Czechia
+ 25 moreDenmark, France, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Taiwan, United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom, Ireland, United States
Delivery and service
Return window30 daysat the median of 396 brands28 daysbelow the median of 396 brands
Free returnsNoNo
Company
Legal entityMack Weldon, Inc.Phase Eight (Fashion & Designs) Limited
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited Kingdom
Support channelsEmail, Chat, Help centreEmail, Chat, Phone, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Mack Weldon

Mack Weldon suits shoppers building a natural fibre wardrobe who want a clear return window and a readable entry price. Prices start at €56, returns are accepted for 30 days, and the trade-off is that return postage is charged and deducted from your refund.

Read the full Mack Weldon review

Phase Eight

Phase Eight suits shoppers in the UK, Ireland and the US who want one womenswear catalog covering dresses, workwear, knitwear and denim, with petite and plus sizes alongside. Returns run 28 days from receipt, though a return fee is deducted from the refund.

Read the full Phase Eight review

How they place

Jeans and denim
Mack Weldon 13 of 129 by score · Phase Eight 14 of 129 by score
Coats, jackets and rainwear
Mack Weldon 35 of 220 by score · Phase Eight 38 of 220 by score

Pros and cons

Mack Weldon

Pros

  • Anything unworn and unwashed can go back for 30 days from purchase, so a fit check at home is on the house.
  • Entry pricing is easy to read, with prices starting at €56.
  • In the EU, delivery is free once an order reaches €180.

Cons

  • Pre-paid returns carry a return shipping fee, and the brand deducts that fee from your refund rather than covering it, so the amount that arrives back is smaller than the amount you paid.
  • The 30 day window leaves out final sale items, which the policy exempts.
  • EU delivery is still charged under €180, which a €56 t-shirt does not reach on its own.

Phase Eight

Pros

  • Returns run 28 days from the day an order arrives, which leaves a comfortable window to try pieces at home.
  • Standard UK delivery is free once an order passes £150, so larger baskets avoid the delivery fee.
  • Material choices lean towards cotton, linen and recycled polyester, with leather in the mix as cotton, organic cotton, linen and more shows.

Cons

  • Free returns are not on offer: return postage costs a fee that is deducted from your refund, so the refunded amount is smaller than the price paid.
  • Sale items sit on a shorter return window than the 28 days period that covers standard pieces.

Who each suits

Mack Weldon

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want to try a fit at home before committing, since unworn and unwashed pieces can come back within 30 days.
  • People who read fabric content before buying, since Mack Weldon states what each fabric is made from.
  • Buyers who prefer to fill a wardrobe from a single brand, since Mack Weldon sells menswear, t shirts and more.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who expect return postage to be covered, since pre-paid returns are charged and the fee is deducted from the refund.
  • Anyone ordering a €56 t-shirt in the EU, since free delivery starts at €180.
  • Anyone buying a final sale piece, since those items sit outside the 30 day return window.

Phase Eight

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who want one catalog for dresses, workwear, knitwear, coats and jeans, with petite and plus sizes in the same place.
  • People who like deciding at home, with 28 days to send an order back after it arrives.
  • Readers who want a stated garment price, since a dress on the site is listed at £89.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers living outside the UK, Ireland and the US, where delivery does not reach.
  • Anyone counting on free returns, since a return fee is deducted from the refund.

Current offers

Mack Weldon

  • Discount code

    20% off first order of $125 or more

    New customers only, full priced orders of $125 or more

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Phase Eight

No offer terms recorded

Questions about each

Mack Weldon

How much is a Mack Weldon shirt?

Prices start at €56 on a t-shirt, and the rest of the range sits above that. Knitwear, jeans, loungewear and coats and jackets each carry their own figure, so the entry price tells you little about what a full wardrobe costs. Open the category you actually plan to shop for the number that matters to you.

How long do I have to send an order back?

Anything unworn and unwashed can be returned for 30 days from the date of purchase, and final sale items are exempt from that window. The clock starts at purchase rather than delivery, which keeps the deadline easy to track even on a long international shipment.

Phase Eight

How much does a dress from Phase Eight cost?

Prices are set on individual pieces rather than in tiers. The Alima Ponte Shift Mini Dress on the dresses pages is listed at £89, and that figure belongs to that dress alone, so knitwear, coats and denim carry their own prices and you would need to look at each piece separately.

How long do I have to return something?

The return window is 28 days, counted from the day an order reaches you rather than from the day it was placed. Sale items sit on a shorter period than standard pieces, so it is worth checking the terms on anything reduced before ordering.

Sources

Mack Weldon

  • mackweldon.com: 10 facts, checked 1 October 2026

Phase Eight

  • phase-eight.com: 10 facts, checked 1 October 2026