Updated 1 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team

Atelier Goldner vs Message

Atelier Goldner

9.3

Pick Atelier Goldner for free returns.

Message

8.6

Pick Message for a longer return window (30 days against 14 days).

See the category

Key differences

  • Atelier Goldner scores higher overall: 9.3 against 8.6.
  • Message has a longer return window (30 days against 14 days).
  • Only Atelier Goldner has free returns.
  • Among support channels, only Atelier Goldner offers Phone.
  • Among products, only Atelier Goldner offers Womenswear, Dresses and Jeans.

Side by side

Atelier Goldner vs Message
Atelier GoldnerMessage
Cost and Other facts
Price from€79.95$150
ProductsWomenswear, Dresses, Jeans, T shirts, Shirts, Basics
+ 7 moreKnitwear, Coats jackets, Loungewear, Suits, Occasion wear, Plus size, Petite
Sandals, Flats, Slippers, Comfort shoes, Barefoot
WidthsWide, Extra wideRegular
MaterialsWool, Cashmere, DenimKnit, Rubber, Recycled
MarketsGermany, Austria, Switzerland, France, Netherlands, Belgium
+ 1 moreFinland
United States
Delivery and service
Return window14 daysbelow the median of 221 brands30 daysat the median of 221 brands
Free returnsYesNo
Worn-shoe returnsNot listedNo
Company
Legal entityGOLDNER GmbHMeghan Whitney LLC
HeadquartersGermanyUnited States
Founded1926Not listed
Support channelsEmail, Phone, Help centreEmail, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Atelier Goldner

Atelier Goldner is a German footwear house worth a look for shoppers in the markets it serves who want wide and extra-wide fits. Entry pricing starts at €79.95, but that figure belongs to a single moccasin, so build the rest of a budget around the pieces themselves.

Read the full Atelier Goldner review

Message

Message makes knit slides and mules for US shoppers who want a sock-like upper and a clear return window. Entry sits at $150, and the pair has to stay unworn, so it suits a shopper deciding quickly rather than someone who wants to test wear.

Read the full Message review

Pros and cons

Atelier Goldner

Pros

  • A trading history back to 1926, so the name sits with established German footwear houses rather than recent online launches.
  • The store is run by GOLDNER GmbH, a company named in its own details, so the party behind an order is easy to pin down.
  • A moccasin with a decorative chain is listed at €79.95, giving a shopper a real listing to weigh other shoes against.

Cons

  • The entry price on record, €79.95, belongs to a moccasin with a decorative chain, so it does not tell you what the rest of the shoe range costs.
  • Orders are dispatched from Germany, so shoppers outside its market group face a cross-border purchase and pay in euro rather than their own currency.
  • Fit is set out as wide and extra-wide widths, so a shopper after a narrow or a very narrow last has no width to search with.

Message

Pros

  • Unworn pairs can go back within 30 days for a full refund.
  • Slides and mules start at $150, so the entry point is easy to weigh.
  • A knit upper wraps the foot like a sock over a natural rubber sole, with a footbed crafted from upcycled wine cork.

Cons

  • Returns need the pair unworn, so an indoor wear test ends the option.

Who each suits

Atelier Goldner

Who it suits

  • Shoppers after wide or extra-wide shoes who would rather browse by fit than by style.
  • Buyers inside the European markets the store serves, paying in euro and comfortable with a German base for dispatch.
  • Repeat buyers of classic closed shoes from a house trading since 1926.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who need a narrow or a very narrow width, since the fit range here runs wide to extra-wide.
  • Anyone budgeting in a currency other than euro who wants the total held in their own money.

Message

Who it suits

  • US shoppers who want a knit slide or mule and can decide within 30 days.
  • People who like a sock-like knit upper over a natural rubber sole.
  • New buyers weighing a clear entry point at $150.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers outside the US, since orders stay in a single market.
  • Anyone who wants to wear a pair indoors and still return it.
  • Buyers whose foot runs wide or narrow, since the footbed comes in a regular fit.

Current offers

Atelier Goldner

Not listed

Message

  • Discount code

    15% off your first order (newsletter signup)

    Email newsletter signup; code emailed to new subscribers.

    Source, checked 1 October 2026

Questions about each

Atelier Goldner

How much do shoes cost at Atelier Goldner?

The store lists an entry figure of €79.95. That price belongs to a moccasin with a decorative chain, so treat it as a starting point rather than a house-wide rate. Shoes are priced piece by piece, and a shopper replacing a whole set of styles should judge each pair on its own listing.

What widths do Atelier Goldner shoes come in?

The store covers wide and extra wide. Shoes are sorted by width and the comfort range pushes out to extra-wide, which is the part of the fit question worth settling before ordering. Anyone buying the same width twice can come back to a familiar shape rather than starting the search from scratch.

Message

How long do I have to return Message shoes?

Customers have 30 days from receiving an order to return an unworn pair for a full refund. The clock starts at delivery rather than at checkout, so a delivery delay eats into the window. Slides and mules fall under the same terms, and the help centre answers process questions when the pairing is unclear.

Are returns free on Message?

A refund covers the price of the pair, while return shipping is charged at a flat rate on every return, so sending a pair back is not costless. The process runs through Frate Returns, and you have 30 days from delivery to get the pair posted. Trying knit slides indoors is realistic; wearing them out is not.