Updated 18 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team
Ariat vs FitVille
Ariat
No. 12 of 196 in women's shoes, heels and sandals9.0Pick Ariat for a longer return window (90 days against 30 days) and free returns.

FitVille
No. 6 of 196 in women's shoes, heels and sandals9.3Pick FitVille for the higher score (9.3 against 9.0).
Key differences
- FitVille scores higher overall: 9.3 against 9.0.
- Ariat has a longer return window (90 days against 30 days).
- Only Ariat has free returns.
- Ariat is available in 48 more countries.
- Among products, only Ariat offers Work boots and Kids shoes.
Side by side
| Ariat | FitVille | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost and Other facts | ||
| Price from | €135 | $79 |
| Products | Boots, Work boots, Sneakers, Loafers, Dress shoes, Slippers+ 1 moreKids shoes | Sneakers, Boots, Sandals, Flats, Loafers, Dress shoes+ 3 moreComfort shoes, Wide fit, Slippers |
| Widths | Narrow, Regular, Wide, Extra wide | Wide, Extra wide |
| Materials | Leather, Suede, Rubber | Suede, Rubber |
| Markets | United States, Antigua and Barbuda, Aruba, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Barbados+ 45 moreBelize, Bermuda, Bolivia, Brazil, Brunei, Cambodia, Canada, Cayman Islands, Costa Rica, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, French Guiana, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, India, Indonesia, Jamaica, Jordan, South Korea, Latvia, Macao, Maldives, Malta, Montserrat, Nicaragua, Oman, Pakistan, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Qatar, Reunion, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Taiwan, Thailand, Trinidad and Tobago, Turkey, Turks and Caicos Islands | United States, Canada, Australia |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Return window | 90 daysHigherin the highest quarter of 221 brands | 30 daysat the median of 221 brands |
| Free returns | Yes | No |
| Worn-shoe returns | No | No |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Ariat International, Inc. | Bylingplanet Inc. |
| Headquarters | United States | Not listed |
| Founded | 1993 | Not listed |
| Support channels | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
Ariat
Ariat suits shoppers who want western and work boots alongside sneakers, dress shoes and kids’ footwear, and who can plan around a 90 days return window on domestic purchases with return postage covered. Entry prices on its cowboy boots start at €135, so the budget stretches if you are shopping to a tight limit.
Read the full Ariat reviewFitVille
FitVille suits a shopper after wide-fit comfort shoes, boots and sneakers who wants a 30-day return window and an entry point of $79 on the featured men’s pair. Free returns are not offered, so an overseas return leaves the shopper covering the postage bill on top of the price already paid.
Read the full FitVille reviewIf neither fits
How they place
- Sneakers
- Ariat 10 of 183 by score · FitVille 4 of 183 by score
- Boots and work boots
- Ariat 10 of 129 by score · FitVille 5 of 129 by score
Pros and cons
Ariat
Pros
- A 90 days return window on domestic purchases, with a prepaid label covering return postage.
- Most items bought online can be sent back at no charge, so a wrong size costs nothing extra to undo.
- Support runs through phone, email, live chat and a self-service help centre, covering both quick and detailed questions.
Cons
- Anything worn cannot go back: items must return unworn with their tags and original packaging, so a tried-on pair is out.
- The 90 days window and covered return postage are written around domestic purchases, so orders shipped outside the US fall outside that cover.
- Delivery outside the US depends on a fixed list of destinations set for the international service, so a country off that list is out of reach.
FitVille
Pros
- A 30-day return window runs from the date an order arrives, so a pair can be tried at home before a decision.
- The featured pair is built from suede and rubber, which the brand credits with support and grip.
- The featured pair is offered in wide and extra wide fits, so a shopper who needs room across the toe has options stated on the product.
Cons
- Free returns are not offered, so international shoppers pay the postage on the return leg themselves.
- Returned items must be in their original condition, unwashed and unworn, so a pair worn outdoors falls outside the window.
- The 30-day clock starts when the parcel arrives, so a slow delivery shortens the time a shopper has to decide.
Who each suits
Ariat
Who it suits
- Riders and outdoor workers looking for western or work boots, plus shoppers who want sneakers and dress footwear from the same brand.
- Anyone who changes their mind often and wants a wide return window with return postage already paid.
- Buyers who need narrow through extra-wide fittings and prefer to sort sizing over chat or email before ordering.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers who wear a pair before deciding, since returns expect unworn items with tags and original packaging.
- Buyers outside the US who want the same return cover as domestic orders.
- Anyone after lightweight footwear, since the range leans on leather and suede.
FitVille
Who it suits
- Shoppers in the US, Canada and Australia who want boots, comfort shoes and sneakers in one place.
- Shoppers who need a wider fit and want a 30-day window to test the pair indoors before keeping it.
- Anyone buying a single pair rather than a plan, with the featured men’s pair at $79 as the figure to weigh.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers who expect free returns on an overseas order, since free returns are not offered and the postage is paid by the customer.
- Anyone who has already worn or washed the shoes they mean to send back, since returns must arrive unworn and unwashed.
- Shoppers outside FitVille’s listed delivery markets who need a confirmed arrival date before ordering.
Current offers
Questions about each
Ariat
What kinds of shoes does Ariat sell?
Ariat’s catalogue covers boots, work boots, sneakers and more. Boots sit at the centre, with sneakers and dress shoes adding everyday options on top. The same brand can cover riding and work wear alongside casual shoes, which suits shoppers who would rather not split an order across several labels.
How long do I have to send a return back?
Returns on domestic purchases stay open for 90 days from the date of purchase. Return postage is covered, so a prepaid label comes with the parcel rather than a bill at the other end. The window counts from the day you buy, not from the day you decide to send it back.
FitVille
How long do I have to return FitVille shoes?
A shopper has 30 days from the date the items are received to send them back, so the clock starts at delivery rather than at the order. Items must arrive in their original condition, unwashed and unworn, which narrows what counts as a valid return.
What does a FitVille pair cost?
FitVille lists $79 as the price of the featured men’s pair, the model the brand quotes at that figure. Nothing is set up as a recurring charge, so a shopper weighing ongoing costs should weigh the cost of the pair at checkout instead.
Sources
Ariat
- ariat.com: 12 facts, checked 1 October 2026
FitVille
- thefitville.com: 10 facts, checked 1 October 2026
