Updated 21 October 2026 · AttireCue Editorial Team
Amiclubwear vs Phase Eight
Amiclubwear
No. 21 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses9.4Best for: Low-cost party and occasion clothing with a store-credit return route.
Phase Eight
No. 45 of 560 in women's clothing and dresses8.7Best for: One catalog for womenswear, workwear and denim, with petite and plus sizes in the same place.
Key differences
- Amiclubwear scores higher overall: 9.4 against 8.7.
- Amiclubwear has a longer return window (30 days against 28 days).
- Among support channels, only Phase Eight offers Chat.
- Phase Eight is available in 1 more country.
- Among products, only Amiclubwear offers Loungewear.
Side by side
| Amiclubwear | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price from | €9.95 | £89 |
| Free delivery threshold | $50 | £150 |
| Other facts | ||
| Products | Womenswear, Dresses, Occasion wear, Knitwear, Coats jackets, Jeans+ 2 moreLoungewear, Plus size | Womenswear, Dresses, Occasion wear, Workwear, Knitwear, Coats jackets+ 3 moreJeans, Petite, Plus size |
| Materials | Lace, Microfiber | Cotton, Organic cotton, Linen, Recycled polyester, Leather |
| Markets | United States, Canada | United Kingdom, Ireland, United States |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Return window | 30 daysat the median of 396 brands | 28 daysbelow the median of 396 brands |
| Free returns | No | No |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Amiclubwear.com | Phase Eight (Fashion & Designs) Limited |
| Headquarters | United States | United Kingdom |
| Support channels | Email, Phone, Help centre | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
Amiclubwear
Amiclubwear suits shoppers who want party and occasion clothing at a low entry price and can live with store credit instead of a cash refund. Dresses are listed from €9.95, and a window counted from the date of receipt gives room to try a dress on at home before keeping it.
Read the full Amiclubwear reviewPhase Eight
Phase Eight suits shoppers in the UK, Ireland and the US who want one womenswear catalog covering dresses, workwear, knitwear and denim, with petite and plus sizes alongside. Returns run 28 days from receipt, though a return fee is deducted from the refund.
Read the full Phase Eight reviewIf neither fits
How they place
- Jeans and denim
- Amiclubwear 5 of 129 by score · Phase Eight 14 of 129 by score
- Coats, jackets and rainwear
- Amiclubwear 16 of 220 by score · Phase Eight 38 of 220 by score
- Wedding, prom and occasion wear
- Amiclubwear 10 of 99 by score · Phase Eight 18 of 99 by score
- Plus-size, petite and tall clothing
- Amiclubwear 7 of 73 by score · Phase Eight 12 of 73 by score
Pros and cons
Amiclubwear
Pros
- One lace dress on the site lists €9.95 in euros, which keeps the cost of trying a piece low.
- The return window is 30 days, counted from the date the parcel reaches you.
- Dresses, jeans and knitwear sit in the same catalogue, so one order can cover an outfit.
Cons
- Free returns are not offered, so a return ends as store credit and the customer pays to send the parcel back.
- Pieces must arrive unworn and unused, since worn returns are not accepted.
- Free standard shipping covers deliveries within the continental US only and cannot be combined with other offers, so baskets under $50 pay postage.
Phase Eight
Pros
- Returns run 28 days from the day an order arrives, which leaves a comfortable window to try pieces at home.
- Standard UK delivery is free once an order passes £150, so larger baskets avoid the delivery fee.
- Material choices lean towards cotton, linen and recycled polyester, with leather in the mix as cotton, organic cotton, linen and more shows.
Cons
- Free returns are not on offer: return postage costs a fee that is deducted from your refund, so the refunded amount is smaller than the price paid.
- Sale items sit on a shorter return window than the 28 days period that covers standard pieces.
Who each suits
Amiclubwear
Who it suits
- Shoppers who want to try a party dress at home before deciding to keep it.
- Anyone clearing $50 in a single order who wants standard shipping at no extra cost.
- Readers who would rather have store credit in hand than wait on a cash refund.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers who need cash back, because returns here end as store credit.
Phase Eight
Who it suits
- Shoppers who want one catalog for dresses, workwear, knitwear, coats and jeans, with petite and plus sizes in the same place.
- People who like deciding at home, with 28 days to send an order back after it arrives.
- Readers who want a stated garment price, since a dress on the site is listed at £89.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers living outside the UK, Ireland and the US, where delivery does not reach.
- Anyone counting on free returns, since a return fee is deducted from the refund.
Questions about each
Amiclubwear
How much does a dress cost?
A lace dress page on the site lists €9.95 in euros, so that gives you the cost of one piece rather than a basket. Postage is added on top unless the order reaches $50, at which point standard shipping to the continental US is free.
How long do I have to send a piece back?
You have 30 days from the date of receipt to send something back. The refund comes as store credit, free returns are not offered, and worn or used pieces are not accepted, so try a dress on indoors before deciding to keep it.
Phase Eight
How much does a dress from Phase Eight cost?
Prices are set on individual pieces rather than in tiers. The Alima Ponte Shift Mini Dress on the dresses pages is listed at £89, and that figure belongs to that dress alone, so knitwear, coats and denim carry their own prices and you would need to look at each piece separately.
How long do I have to return something?
The return window is 28 days, counted from the day an order reaches you rather than from the day it was placed. Sale items sit on a shorter period than standard pieces, so it is worth checking the terms on anything reduced before ordering.
Sources
Amiclubwear
- amiclubwear.com: 10 facts, checked 1 October 2026
Phase Eight
- phase-eight.com: 10 facts, checked 1 October 2026



